AND HOW HARD IS IT? If you think of it in terms of the biblical myth of Satan, or the casting down of a literary Lucifer, you are lost in “metaphysics,” which is imaginary narrative of a drama taking place in the Never-Never Land of a supernatural “Other World” along with or without dragons and unicorns.
If, instead, you think of it as metaphoric to, or allegorical of, our real human condition, you are not far off. Our “fallen condition” is awful — but we actually know nothing else.
Within the social culture in which our personalities develop, suddenly blooming around age 3 or 4 we find ourselves as “persons” increasingly aware of self and others, possessing, and largely possessed by, language. Human speech brings with it the web of words that liberates, empowers and entraps or disables our minds about equally.
Consider the one-ness of all things we “knew-without-awareness” before we were born, and that same, unknowable unity we enter upon death. After we are born physically and get born mentally as individual people, we “fall” from insensible nothingness into conscious lives mediated by language. Language and its wordiness divides our sensible existence up and breaks it down into manageable divisions, particular units of sound associated with meanings that we can organize into sentences, just as cold type letters can be organized into lines of print. Word-meanings involve general ideas or concepts.
The conceptual structures and classifications in our heads enable us, as the philosopher Immanuel Kant indicated (and as adjusted by the “General Semantics” writers), to construct a nearly reliable model world that has much in common with everyone else’s models, though the consensus is never quite perfect. Sometimes we are wildly at odds. Each person sees a different model, though trustful of living in the same world “out there,” a world that according to Kant (and much epistemology) we can never contact or sense directly, because that “out there” is mediated by sensation and filtered by our perceptual order of concepts “in here” that divides and classifies it into categories and speakable units. In effect, we sense our ideas of sensed objects, not the objects. Our perception “negotiates” whatever data comes though sensation into ideation.
We fall, then, twice — first at birth from biological precursors (the objective nothingness of the not-yet) into “particular embodiment,” and second, from “mental nowhere-ness” into “awakened here-and-now-ness.” From there we grow empowered with familial love or cut to shreds, maybe forever, by inconsiderate parenting and/or religious severities.
Religion too often becomes the instrument of extreme verbalism. Enforcement of rote doctrine and belief supported only by presumed authority, such as ancient scripture and its time-invested aura of superstitions (invested without digestion) endlessly repeated, puts the young into mental straitjackets from which they seldom mature enough to escape into the mental and emotional freedom of current, state-of-the-art outlook.
Thus we see rampant, fanatical fundamentalism among the least fundamentally mental and emotionally responsible people among us in American society. These people, fanatically certain about who they are, what they want and what everyone else needs, are the ones who know least about those things and are least equipped to meet the nation’s needs.
A worst-case scenario: Suppose there is a “secret plot” by the most powerful?
Let’s say there are elite circles high in our society that know about extraterrestrial visits by galactic aliens with whom relations are established and information has been exchanged, even perhaps including treaties. Much of our information would have come from back-engineering alien technology from ships and devices wrecked on Earth or otherwise given to us to support our advancement into their unimaginable universe, with, of course, suitable profit to some big corporations. They keep their knowledge from the public.
Suppose further that these powerfully high “insiders” have minds as half-baked and twisted as many in the tea party or the Koch brothers themselves and our poor, old, rich media tycoon, Rupert Murdoch, who has, like the Koch family, vast reason to be content but always itches for more! George Bush himself has been speaking to and encouraging people in the ultra-right’s religious bubble-full of nutcases! They include millennialists who await the Second Coming as the Great Rapture off our planet of all the Faithful.
And suppose, again, that this cabal of demented upper-crust folks has a treaty with an alien entity to come in ships and carry off all the willing members of that bunch to live on a compatible planet far across the galaxy. Would those of us Left Behind suffer the dregs of loss and decline — or would we, impeded no longer by craziness in the halls of governance, be able to construct a heavenly democracy with a good way to live productively through good work and with decent, mutual discipline on an enjoyable but properly respected Earth? Shantih!
May we escape the bewitched enchantments into an only benevolently enchanted world, since our minds work only by magic. May peace then well up within us with clear insight and understanding toward all. What a glorious surprise it would be, to awaken to that.
Robert Shelby was poet laureate of Benicia from 2008-10.
robert Livesay says
Robert you ran out of words and did terll the readers what you wanted to say. You dislike the Tea Party, Murdoch and the Koch Brothers. All the readers had to do was scroll down to what you really wanted to say. All the words were not read nor were they necessary or for sure without any meaning except to you and your handy word guide right by your computer.
environmentalpro says
Thesaurus?
robert Livesay says
SAt least you agree. Thank you.
environmentalpro says
I agree that you used to many words, when you simply could have used one word.
Hank Harrison says
His word guide is his mind, expanded and improved by years of studying the human condition. Would that we all had a word guide as “handy” as Robert Shelby’s.
robert Livesay says
Glad you read and agreed with my comment. Thanks Hank. You did agree with the handy word guide comment? I assume.
Hank Harrison says
Let Bob’s reading comprehension skills serve as a warning: Stay in school, kids.
robert Livesay says
You see Hank I think RMS writing belongs on the funny pages where most of the Liberals can giggle and pretend they understsand what he is writing. I understand everything he writes and I must admit it is comical and very shallow. Capire
Hank Harrison says
“I understand everything he writes”
No
JLB says
It makes me sad to see someone that is so against the concept of there being a God of the universe and so repulsed by the idea to verbal chastise any that would think so. I have had too many personal experiences in my life to deny that there is a God and He has influence over my life. All of the hatred, anger and distain for others that RMS clearly holds onto and spews verbally upon others in these columns, is clear evidence of a troubled soul. It makes me wonder what terrible thing happened to him in his life that destined him to this disposition. I pray that he sees the light and turns toward God before his death, otherwise he will be a lost soul forever in a see of darkness.
Hank Harrison says
The See of darkness is in Rome.
environmentalpro says
And how are you being any better in pointing out that you think he is wrong and that he will be punished?
DDL says
JLB Stated: All of the hatred, anger and distain for others that RMS clearly holds onto and spews verbally upon others in these columns, is clear evidence of a troubled soul.
Good point JLB. Extended a bit further: His contempt for any form of humanity that advocates a contrary opinion is even more evident on his personal Blog, as well as his responses here, not as a columnist, but as a private person.
Hank Harrison says
Hey thanks for the tip! Everyone check out Robert’s great blog:
http://www.robertmshelbypoetry.com/wordpress/
robert Livesay says
That was good Dennis. I am sure it will get the money persuing poety in an uproar. Oh sorry I forgot poets do not make money.
JLB says
I guess if you are having a private discussion at Starbucks, you better make sure to look around you and make sure that RMS is not sitting anywhere near you, cause in his own words, he is an eves dropper.
JLB says
No comments on his blog that I can read anywhere. Could it be that no one reads it but him? Most likely!
DDL says
He does not allow posts. Apparently he reads them, but they never appear on his ‘blog’.
John Cosmides says
Mr. Shelby,
You accurately describe the consequences of man’s fall in Eden. By choosing autonomy over theonomy Adam predestined us to interpret Creation by our senses alone, without God’s revelatory explanation of what we’re observing. And, as you explained, my senses don’t interpret reality the way your senses do, and my words don’t have the same meaning to you as they do to me. So, we are each doomed to live within our unique worldview, incapable of truly conveying that view to others. We have no hope of building a “heavenly democracy” (your words) on earth because we can never agree on what it should look like or be certain that we’re even talking about the same democracy.