Benicia Herald

  • Front Page
  • News
    • Features
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Forum
  • The Arts
    • Poetry
  • About The Herald
  • May 24, 2025

Choice is power, and the choice is yours

March 14, 2015 by Dawn Weisz 9 Comments

MARIN CLEAN ENERGY IS BENICIA’S NEW ELECTRICITY PROVIDER. We offer cleaner energy service and lower rates to help the environment and save you money. If you have questions about MCE, how it works or how it affects you as a resident or business in Benicia, please keep reading. Below are answers to the most common questions we hear about MCE.

Because MCE is now Benicia’s default electricity provider, if you have a PG&E account you will start MCE Light Green 50-percent renewable electric service automatically in May, unless you choose another option.

You may also choose MCE’s Deep Green 100-percent renewable energy by opting up, or PG&E’s 22-percent renewable energy by opting out. PG&E will continue providing electric delivery and billing services to MCE customers.

Is MCE’s power cleaner than PG&E’s? Yes.

By all measures, MCE provides cleaner energy options to Benicia residents and businesses.

According to 2013 California Energy Commission power content labels, MCE’s Light Green service was 51-percent renewable — which includes solar, wind, bioenergy, geothermal and small hydroelectricity — compared to PG&E’s 22-percent renewable. Figures for 2014 have not yet been verified. The most recent, publicly verified power content is from 2013. Renewables .

These same power content labels show that MCE’s Light Green service was 61-percent carbon-free in 2013 compared to PG&E’s 54 percent. Renewable energy, large hydroelectricity and nuclear energy is considered carbon free. MCE’s power supply does not include nuclear.

MCE’s Light Green greenhouse gas (GHG) emission rate for 2013 was 363.7 pounds of carbon dioxide per megawatt hour. PG&E’s GHG emission rate was 427 pounds CO2/MWh.

MCE is in good standing with state regulatory agencies and voluntarily submits its Deep Green, 100-percent renewable energy data for verification by an independent third party called Green-e.

Are MCE’s rates less expensive than PG&E’s? Yes.

MCE’s rates are currently lower, and they are also more stable. Since operations began in 2010, rates have only changed once a year, in April. MCE does not guarantee that rates will always be lower, because PG&E tends to change rates three to five times per year.

MCE will increase rates by 4.2 percent in April. The April rates are used in all cost comparisons, since Benicia’s enrollment is taking place in May. Even after the increase, all MCE rates will remain lower than PG&E’s.

MCE Light Green service will annually save the typical residential and commercial customers about $17 and $166, respectively. In 2014, MCE saved customers more than $5.9 million!

MCE customers continue to receive financial assistance on their bills through CARE, FERA and/or the Medical Baseline allowance.

What does MCE offer Benicia? Choice, savings, green jobs and more!

MCE creates choice where there was none by offering two new options for energy service: Light Green, 50-percent renewable energy, and Deep Green, 100-percent renewable energy.

Those who choose Light Green service have savings opportunities on their monthly PG&E bill. In 2014 the city of Richmond saved approximately $107,000 through MCE, and the West Contra Costa Unified School District has saved approximately $66,000 since its enrollment. The county of Marin met its greenhouse gas reductions goals eight years early, in part because of MCE.

MCE has more than 193 megawatts (MW) of new California clean energy under development for its customers, including a 10-MW solar project at Chevron-owned property in Richmond. MCE’s contracted power projects have generated more than 2,400 California jobs.

MCE offers new programs tailored to your community: energy efficiency programs, electric vehicle pilot programs, an innovative battery storage program, on-bill repayment of solar loans and much more.

What kind of organization is MCE?

MCE is a locally controlled, not-for-profit community choice aggregator. As a local government agency and public servant, MCE is always working in the best interests of our member communities.

By joining MCE, Benicia now has local control to ensure that the high prices and volatility that took place during the energy crisis of 2000 won’t happen again. The city of Benicia got a seat on the MCE board when it voted to join; Alan Schwartzman was selected by the Benicia City Council to fill that seat.

MCE does not use taxpayer dollars. It reinvests in communities by providing low and stable rates, fostering local renewable development projects and expanding energy efficiency programs.

MCE is governed by a board of directors made up of locally elected council members who represent each of our member communities. MCE’s board of directors is not paid by MCE.

Why does MCE enroll customers automatically?

Historically, investor-owned utilities have been the default service provider to customers in their jurisdictions. However, in 2002, when state legislators passed California’s Community Choice Aggregation (CCA) law, this default status was transferred from the investor-owned utility to the local CCA. Reflecting the wisdom of collective community action, the original CCA legislation mandated that customers residing in a service area be automatically enrolled unless they chose not to participate by opting out.

How do I get more information or opt out?

Visit MCE’s website at mceCleanEnergy.org/Benicia, email info@mceCleanEnergy.org or call 888-632-3674. To inform residents and businesses, MCE is also arranging presentations for local organizations and clubs. Public meetings are listed on our website. If you would like to schedule a presentation for your group, please email info@mceCleanEnergy.org.

MCE is an “opt out” program as required by state law, not by marketing design. MCE has made every effort to make the opt out process simple and efficient. To ensure that people are aware of the change in their electric service, MCE mails five separate notices to all Benicia electric customers.

All ratepayers can opt out of MCE either by calling 888-632-3674 or doing so online at mcecleanenergy.org/opt-out. Please have your PG&E account number on hand, because we will need it to process your request.

Dawn Weisz is the executive officer for the Marin Energy Authority. She coordinated efforts to explore and launch the Marin Clean Energy program, the first community choice aggregation program in California.

Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on RedditShare on StumbleUponPin on Pinterest
Sharing is caring!

Filed Under: Features, Front Page, Opinion

Comments

  1. Benicia Dave says

    March 14, 2015 at 2:16 pm

    Are the rates charged by MEC regulated by the PUC? Does any rate increase need to go through the PUC before being enacted? Is MEC regulated by anyone other than the BOD?
    What are the tier rates charged by MEC? I can only currently find the one rate (an average) but I could not find on the MEC web page what the tier 2 through 4 rates are.

    Reply
  2. DDL says

    March 14, 2015 at 2:33 pm

    Interesting headline: Choice is power, and the choice is yours

    But the choice to join MCE was made by the City leaders and not by the residents of Benicia. Choice is indeed power and the choice by the City power brokers was to deny a choice to the residents.

    And no, “opt out” is not really a ‘choice’, it is a ploy.

    Reply
  3. Tom says

    March 14, 2015 at 2:47 pm

    Thanks Dawn. I never received the mailed flyer. Your opt-out link above works great. I’ll stick with PG&E thank you very much.

    Reply
  4. Heather Dunn says

    March 14, 2015 at 7:19 pm

    I think the only thing we hate more than PG&E is having this forced upon us. I have opted OUT.

    Reply
  5. Heather Dunn says

    March 14, 2015 at 7:20 pm

    It’s amazing to me how many of my neighbors didn’t get the opt out mailer. This whole thing is fishy.

    Reply
  6. john says

    March 14, 2015 at 8:08 pm

    The mailer, as noted in a previous article , looked a lot like junk mail. I knew it was coming and kept an eye out for it and opted out the first chance I got. This is a crock – and I am upset with each and every elected official who supported this being crammed down our throats. All in the name of not wanting to upset a voting bloc. Sell out on the local level.

    Reply
  7. Stan Golovich says

    March 15, 2015 at 8:57 am

    Here is how the EPA defines a “green tag”, the instrument MCE uses to indicate their shade of green.

    “A REC (pronounced: rěk) represents the property rights to the environmental, social, and other non power qualities of renewable electricity generation. A REC, and its associated attributes and benefits, can be sold separately from the underlying physical electricity associated with a renewable-based generation source.”

    Reply
  8. Old timer says

    March 15, 2015 at 1:42 pm

    Anybody remember ENRON and its promises???

    Reply
    • DDL says

      March 15, 2015 at 2:15 pm

      Anybody remember ENRON and its promises???

      I’m sure former Enron advisor Paul Krugman would prefer to forget those promises.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Browse by Category

Hot Off the Press

Benicia Herald Candidate Questionnaire responses

Auction of Jerrold Turner paintings to benefit Arts Benicia

Benicia City Council appoints Interim City Manager

Benicia Firefighter tests positive for COVID-19

Benicia’s Troop 7007 adds two new Eagle Scouts to its ranks

Reader Comments

  • Peggy on Bluebird of Happiness returns
  • Oliver Greenwood on Served, and serving, proudly
  • David Batchelor on Reg Page: Memories of Benicia
  • Colin larkin on Scott Swartz named new BHS varsity football head coach
  • max kirkpatrick on Fitzgerald Field is getting a makeover
  • Tracy Fetter on Fitzgerald Field makeover may be completed by end of April
  • Michael Lagrimas on Candidate Spotlight: EDB Chair Lionel Largaespada taking another shot at council seat

Popular Articles

Ace Hardware owner: We may move

Do Benicians want tar-sands oil brought here?

Dennis Lund: George Zimmerman’s ‘Oxbow Incident’

Jerome Page: It’s not inequality, it’s envy!

Science with the odor of oil

The good guys win

Copyright © 2025 · News Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in